The Deals We Don't Study
- Why We Study the Wins
Every commercial team I know reviews its wins. Almost none interview the buyer who decided to do nothing.
The win review is a sensible habit. The deal closed, the rep was there for most of it, and the story has an ending you can learn from. We know who decided, what they compared us against, and roughly why we came out ahead. Losses get a review too, when there's a competitor to name.
For most of this industry's history, that was close to the whole picture. The rep sat in the middle of the decision. They heard the objections, met the plant manager, watched the trial go well or badly. Ask the rep how the customer decided and you got a reasonable account, because the rep had seen most of it.
Bob Lurie, former head of strategy at Eastman and before that two decades a growth consultant at Monitor, put the change bluntly when he joined one of our roundtables. Salespeople will tell you they know how their customers decide. "Actually, what they really understand is the negotiation process." They understand what procurement allows them to see, and "they really don't know how the hell things happen up behind the wall."
So the win review studies the part of the decision we could see. The deals that end in no decision leave nothing to review at all. No competitor to blame, no loss report, nobody who feels owed an explanation. The buyer goes quiet, and the opportunity ages out of the CRM.
Those are the deals with the most to tell us, and we don't study them.
Post-Mortems Tell Us More
A deal that dies quietly died somewhere. Something in the buyer's own process stopped it: a question nobody inside could answer, a person who couldn't carry the case, a step that ran out of energy. A win review can't show you that point, because in a win the buyer got past it. A post-mortem on a stalled deal can, because the stall is the whole story.
The objection I hear is that every customer is different, so what one stalled buyer tells you won't generalize. Lurie's experience says otherwise. By his estimate he has mapped how customers actually make decisions 100 to 150 times, across industries, and without fail the team looks at the map and says some version of "oh, I didn't know they were doing that." There is a critical role, or a critical step, that nobody on the supplier side had seen.
And it recurs. To know the people by name, you need to know the company. To know the role and the place in the process where the decision really gets made, "it's astonishing how common it is."
That's what makes this work doable rather than endless. Where buyers get stuck isn't a private mystery inside each account. It's a place in their process, and it's roughly the same place from one company to the next. It's findable.
It also tends to look obvious once it's found. Lurie described teams greeting a finding with a big "duh," and one client team arguing with his numbers for a month and a half. Obvious afterward is not the same as known beforehand. If it were, somebody would already have acted on it.
This is the part I find encouraging. Sales, by the nature of the job, sees what the wall lets through. Marketing isn't bound to the negotiation. It can go and talk to the people who've done the job on the customer's side, and to the buyers who walked away, and come back with a picture of the decision nobody in the company has had. That's harder than producing another campaign, and it's the work that tells the whole business where the sale is actually won and lost.
Actioning the Insight
- Map the decision from outside the deal. Talk to people who have done the job on the customer's side: industry veterans, former customer-side staff, your own colleagues who came from customers. Build your own map of how a decision gets made, and look for the role and the step you didn't know about.
- Run the post-mortem on the deals that stalled. Interview the buyers who went to no decision, not the ones you won. Ask what was hardest about the whole process, and what advice they'd give a peer about to start it. Write down where they couldn't answer their own question, in their words rather than as a funnel stage.
- Rank the stall points by what they cost, and pick one. You'll find more than one, and the temptation is to build for all of them. Start with the one that stops the most decisions.
The deals we lost to nobody have the most to tell us, and they're the only ones we never ask.
Until next week,
Kendall -

Find me on LinkedIn or Book a 1:1 call
Not a subscriber yet? Subscribe here